In the early 1990s, Katie DeWitt James left her home with her baby, Lulu, after filing for divorce from her abusive husband. She had plans to move in with her cousin, but instead, moved in with a local prostitute, Frannie Norton, in Weatherford, Oklahoma. Katie was last seen leaving the house with her baby and Frannie; however, none of them returned.

Katie was missing and Frannie had taken Lulu to a farm and left her there. After Frannie was caught, taken into custody, and questioned by police, she poisoned herself. A month later, in Deer Creek, a fully-clothed skeleton was found, along with the skull 3 feet away with a bullet in it and the caliber gun sitting nearby. It was concluded that Frannie had killed Katie the month prior. People have heard a woman looking for her baby and the sound of rolling wheels, and have seen Katie appearing as blue light.